Penner StrategyQuestions & evidence

School spending · Edition 0002

Inflation shrinks or reverses the spending increase

Using the U.S. CPI-U (mean index 285.848 in 2021-22, 319.205 in 2024-25), the increase in spending per enrollment unit falls to 0.8%. Using the Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue area CPI-U (mean 314.668 in 2021-22, 359.602 in 2024-25), spending per enrollment unit fell 1.5%.

Finding ID: f-inflation-adjusted · Published status: supported

Qualifications

Inflation adjustment

Spending per enrollment unit is divided by the mean of that school year's monthly consumer price index readings, using either the U.S. or the Seattle-area CPI-U series.

Why are there two inflation-adjusted figures?

One uses the U.S. city-average CPI-U (12 monthly readings per year); the other uses the Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue area CPI-U (published every second month, 6 readings per year). They give 0.8% and -1.5% respectively.

Reported values

ValuePublished displayUnitRounding
Change after U.S. city-average consumer prices0.8%percentExact ratio; display rounded half-up to one place.
Change after Seattle-area consumer prices-1.5%percentExact ratio; display rounded half-up to one place.

Reasoning in the published record

Each school year's index is the mean of its monthly observations, and the adjusted change divides the spending ratio by the ratio of those two means.

How is each inflation-adjustment window built?

Each school year's price index is the mean of its September-to-August monthly readings; the U.S. series uses 12 monthly observations per year, the Seattle-area series publishes every second month and supplies 6.

Findings used as premises

Evidence that could change the finding

Using a school-specific input-cost index instead of a general consumer price index.

Checks and source evidence

Both window means were recomputed from the retained observation file and their observation counts checked. The adjustment arithmetic was recomputed exactly.

The following outcomes are the published historical checks. Their original dates, scope and exclusions are retained here.

Monthly index observations in every window used

The U.S. window means are 254.016, 257.721, 285.848 and 319.205 index points from twelve observations each; the Seattle-area window means are 276.181, 281.110, 314.668 and 359.602 from six observations each.

Locator: {"kind": "data_selection", "reference": "fields series_id, school_year, month and value; the 72 rows for September through August of the 2018-19, 2019-20, 2021-22 and 2024-25 school years in both series; annual-average records excluded."}

Captured source: CPI-U series CUUR0000SA0 and CUURS49DSA0, 2018 to 2025

Publisher source

Recorded source SHA-256: 261d45b739de5d6bee001b6e7d479a192cf367ef1197407d5a22fb3aef923602

Statewide General Fund expenditures, 2024-25

Grand Total, 24-25: 21081063857.94.

Locator: {"kind": "table_cell", "reference": "Sheet 'EXP by District', row 'Grand Total', column '24-25'"}

Captured source: Ten-year F-196 financial summary workbook, 2024-25

Publisher source

Recorded source SHA-256: a4d5bd7796c6eb364e625c2ff46844c4539ceb224648d1f852cfadeb12900098

Associated published artifacts

Citation

Penner Strategy. The increase shrinks or reverses once consumer-price inflation is factored in. Edition 0002. https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/findings/f-inflation-adjusted/

Complete original record
{
  "argument": {
    "counterevidence_ids": [],
    "evidence_ids": [
      "e-cpi-observations"
    ],
    "panels": [
      {
        "evidence_ids": [
          "e-cpi-observations"
        ],
        "panel_id": "p-inflation-window",
        "qualification_ids": [
          "qual-consumer-prices"
        ],
        "question": "How is each inflation-adjustment window built?",
        "takeaway": "Each school year's price index is the mean of its September-to-August monthly readings; the U.S. series uses 12 monthly observations per year, the Seattle-area series publishes every second month and supplies 6."
      }
    ],
    "premise_finding_ids": [
      "f-nominal-growth"
    ],
    "reasoning": "Each school year's index is the mean of its monthly observations, and the adjusted change divides the spending ratio by the ratio of those two means.",
    "unresolved_alternatives": [
      "A school input-cost index could give a different adjusted change; none is used here."
    ]
  },
  "artifact_ids": [
    "artifact-cpi-observations",
    "artifact-cpi-means",
    "artifact-growth-recipe"
  ],
  "calculation_ids": [
    "calc-statewide-growth"
  ],
  "check_ids": [
    "check-cpi-window",
    "check-statewide-arithmetic"
  ],
  "check_scope": "Both window means were recomputed from the retained observation file and their observation counts checked. The adjustment arithmetic was recomputed exactly.",
  "evidence_ids": [
    "e-cpi-observations",
    "e-expenditures-2425"
  ],
  "finding_id": "f-inflation-adjusted",
  "kind": "calculation",
  "material_qualifications": [
    {
      "effect": "limits_inference",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-cpi-observations"
      ],
      "qualification_id": "qual-consumer-prices",
      "text": "CPI-U measures general consumer prices, not the prices schools themselves pay for staff, materials or services, and no school input-cost index is used here."
    },
    {
      "effect": "limits_inference",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-enrollment-definition"
      ],
      "qualification_id": "qual-enrollment-measure",
      "text": "The denominator is OSPI financial-summary enrollment, which mixes full-time-equivalent K-12 enrollment with birth-to-five special-education headcounts and various institutional programs, so it is not a count of individual K-12 students."
    },
    {
      "effect": "limits_scope",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-expenditures-2122",
        "e-expenditures-2425"
      ],
      "qualification_id": "qual-endpoint-years",
      "text": "Each comparison uses only its two endpoint school years; the years between them, including 2020-21, are not examined, even though the workbook holds other years."
    },
    {
      "effect": "limits_inference",
      "evidence_ids": [],
      "qualification_id": "qual-no-causes",
      "text": "Nothing here establishes the causes of these changes, or speaks to adequacy, efficiency, educational quality or district reserve levels."
    }
  ],
  "reader_context": [
    {
      "answer": "Spending per enrollment unit is divided by the mean of that school year's monthly consumer price index readings, using either the U.S. or the Seattle-area CPI-U series.",
      "context_id": "rc-real-terms",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-cpi-observations"
      ],
      "question": "What does 'adjusted for inflation' mean here?",
      "status": "supported",
      "visible_near": "The first inflation-adjusted figure."
    },
    {
      "answer": "One uses the U.S. city-average CPI-U (12 monthly readings per year); the other uses the Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue area CPI-U (published every second month, 6 readings per year). They give 0.8% and -1.5% respectively.",
      "context_id": "rc-seattle-index",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-cpi-observations"
      ],
      "question": "Why are there two inflation-adjusted figures?",
      "status": "supported",
      "visible_near": "The two different inflation results."
    }
  ],
  "scope_id": "scope-wa-k12",
  "state": "supported",
  "text": "Using the U.S. CPI-U (mean index 285.848 in 2021-22, 319.205 in 2024-25), the increase in spending per enrollment unit falls to 0.8%. Using the Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue area CPI-U (mean 314.668 in 2021-22, 359.602 in 2024-25), spending per enrollment unit fell 1.5%.",
  "title": "The increase shrinks or reverses once consumer-price inflation is factored in",
  "values": [
    {
      "definition_id": "def-real-change",
      "denominator": "Spending per enrollment unit in 2021-22, divided by the ratio of the two U.S. index means.",
      "display": "0.8%",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-cpi-observations",
        "e-expenditures-2425"
      ],
      "exact": {
        "denominator": "1069266359121764558980909",
        "numerator": "827529134341240703227550"
      },
      "label": "Change after U.S. city-average consumer prices",
      "rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to one place.",
      "uncertainty": {
        "description": "Exact arithmetic over reported index values; the index itself measures consumer prices, not school input prices.",
        "kind": "none_quantified"
      },
      "unit": "percent",
      "value_id": "value-real-growth-us"
    },
    {
      "definition_id": "def-real-change",
      "denominator": "Spending per enrollment unit in 2021-22, divided by the ratio of the two Seattle-area index means.",
      "display": "-1.5%",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-cpi-observations"
      ],
      "exact": {
        "denominator": "36137605275153421028294639",
        "numerator": "-55213608995453181077452400"
      },
      "label": "Change after Seattle-area consumer prices",
      "rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to one place.",
      "uncertainty": {
        "description": "Exact arithmetic over six bimonthly observations per window.",
        "kind": "none_quantified"
      },
      "unit": "percent",
      "value_id": "value-real-growth-seattle"
    }
  ],
  "would_change": "Using a school-specific input-cost index instead of a general consumer price index."
}