Penner StrategyQuestions & evidence

School spending · Edition 0002

Basic Education and Special Ed had the largest per-unit spending increases

Per enrollment unit, the largest increases came from Basic Education (+$977.79), Special Ed state funding (+$809.37) and districtwide support (+$397.47). The largest decreases came from ESSER III (-$314.27), ESSER II (-$251.63) and SLFRF enrollment stabilization (-$188.36). These selected program bars do not need to sum to the statewide change.

Finding ID: f-program-mix · Published status: supported

Qualifications

Does every district report every year?

No. Of 326 listed reporting entities, 318 reported General Fund expenditures in 2021-22 and 319 in 2024-25; 319 and 326 carried an enrollment value in those years.

Reported values

ValuePublished displayUnitRounding
Change per enrollment unit, Basic Education977.79dollars per enrollment unitExact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.
Change per enrollment unit, state Special Education809.37dollars per enrollment unitExact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.
Change per enrollment unit, Districtwide support397.47dollars per enrollment unitExact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.
Change per enrollment unit, ESSER III-314.27dollars per enrollment unitExact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.
Change per enrollment unit, ESSER II-251.63dollars per enrollment unitExact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.
Change per enrollment unit, SLFRF enrollment stabilization-188.36dollars per enrollment unitExact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.

Reasoning in the published record

Each program's contribution is its own spending per enrollment unit in the later year minus the same ratio in the earlier year.

Which programs drove the change in spending per enrollment unit?

The chart shows the eight largest per-unit increases, led by Basic Education and Special Ed, and the six largest decreases, led by ESSER III and ESSER II; selected bars need not sum to the statewide change.

Bar chart of program changes in dollars per enrollment unit.
Change in dollars per enrollment unit for the eight largest increases and six largest decreases by program.
Open complete chart record

Findings used as premises

Evidence that could change the finding

A revision by OSPI to either year's program-level totals.

Checks and source evidence

All fourteen plotted program changes were recomputed from the captured workbook and matched the plotted rows exactly.

The following outcomes are the published historical checks. Their original dates, scope and exclusions are retained here.

Plotted program changes per enrollment unit

Basic Education rises 977.7944385197296 dollars per enrollment unit and ESSER III falls 314.26704545482824, with the remaining twelve plotted rows in assets/data/program-contributions.csv.

Locator: {"kind": "data_selection", "reference": "Sheet 'EXP by Program'; fields program and pp_change_dollars; the 14 rows with the eight largest increases and six largest decreases; all other program rows excluded."}

Captured source: Ten-year F-196 financial summary workbook, 2024-25

Publisher source

Recorded source SHA-256: a4d5bd7796c6eb364e625c2ff46844c4539ceb224648d1f852cfadeb12900098

Program titles for the selected codes

Programs 11, 12, 13, 14, 19 and 23 are SLFRF enrollment stabilization, ESSER II, ESSER III, ESSER III learning loss, other CARES Act spending and ARP-IDEA special education.

Locator: {"kind": "record", "reference": "Programs sheet, codes 11, 12, 13, 14, 19 and 23"}

Captured source: F-196 accounting manual program codes, 2024-25

Publisher source

Recorded source SHA-256: ff7aa012099e60d4e007066b9a584634e13bfa530c95c6594e2b88a81374fae2

Associated published artifacts

Citation

Penner Strategy. Basic Education and Special Ed had the largest per-unit spending increases. Edition 0002. https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/findings/f-program-mix/

Complete original record
{
  "argument": {
    "counterevidence_ids": [],
    "evidence_ids": [
      "e-program-contributions"
    ],
    "panels": [
      {
        "artifact_id": "artifact-programs-figure",
        "data_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-data",
        "evidence_ids": [
          "e-program-contributions"
        ],
        "panel_id": "p-program-mix",
        "qualification_ids": [
          "qual-relief-selection",
          "qual-enrollment-measure"
        ],
        "question": "Which programs drove the change in spending per enrollment unit?",
        "takeaway": "The chart shows the eight largest per-unit increases, led by Basic Education and Special Ed, and the six largest decreases, led by ESSER III and ESSER II; selected bars need not sum to the statewide change."
      }
    ],
    "premise_finding_ids": [
      "f-nominal-growth"
    ],
    "reasoning": "Each program's contribution is its own spending per enrollment unit in the later year minus the same ratio in the earlier year.",
    "unresolved_alternatives": [
      "Only the largest increases and decreases are drawn, so the selected bars need not sum to the statewide change."
    ]
  },
  "artifact_ids": [
    "artifact-programs-figure",
    "artifact-programs-data",
    "artifact-program-expenditures"
  ],
  "calculation_ids": [],
  "check_ids": [
    "check-source-verification"
  ],
  "check_scope": "All fourteen plotted program changes were recomputed from the captured workbook and matched the plotted rows exactly.",
  "evidence_ids": [
    "e-program-contributions",
    "e-program-codes"
  ],
  "finding_id": "f-program-mix",
  "kind": "observation",
  "material_qualifications": [
    {
      "effect": "limits_scope",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-relief-programs",
        "e-program-codes"
      ],
      "qualification_id": "qual-relief-selection",
      "text": "The selected relief programs are an explicit choice of six OSPI codes, including program 23, and differ from OSPI's own five-code CARES grouping."
    },
    {
      "effect": "limits_inference",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-enrollment-definition"
      ],
      "qualification_id": "qual-enrollment-measure",
      "text": "The denominator is OSPI financial-summary enrollment, which mixes full-time-equivalent K-12 enrollment with birth-to-five special-education headcounts and various institutional programs, so it is not a count of individual K-12 students."
    },
    {
      "effect": "limits_inference",
      "evidence_ids": [],
      "qualification_id": "qual-no-causes",
      "text": "Nothing here establishes the causes of these changes, or speaks to adequacy, efficiency, educational quality or district reserve levels."
    }
  ],
  "reader_context": [
    {
      "answer": "No. Of 326 listed reporting entities, 318 reported General Fund expenditures in 2021-22 and 319 in 2024-25; 319 and 326 carried an enrollment value in those years.",
      "context_id": "rc-program-coverage",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-program-contributions"
      ],
      "question": "Does every district report every year?",
      "status": "supported",
      "visible_near": "The program chart."
    }
  ],
  "scope_id": "scope-wa-k12",
  "state": "supported",
  "text": "Per enrollment unit, the largest increases came from Basic Education (+$977.79), Special Ed state funding (+$809.37) and districtwide support (+$397.47). The largest decreases came from ESSER III (-$314.27), ESSER II (-$251.63) and SLFRF enrollment stabilization (-$188.36). These selected program bars do not need to sum to the statewide change.",
  "title": "Basic Education and Special Ed had the largest per-unit spending increases",
  "values": [
    {
      "definition_id": "def-program",
      "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in each year.",
      "display": "977.79",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-program-contributions"
      ],
      "exact": {
        "denominator": "625000000000",
        "numerator": "611121524074831"
      },
      "label": "Change per enrollment unit, Basic Education",
      "rounding": "Exact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
      "uncertainty": {
        "description": "An exact difference of two reported ratios.",
        "kind": "none_quantified"
      },
      "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
      "value_id": "value-basic-education-change"
    },
    {
      "definition_id": "def-program",
      "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in each year.",
      "display": "809.37",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-program-contributions"
      ],
      "exact": {
        "denominator": "2000000000000",
        "numerator": "1618737993278417"
      },
      "label": "Change per enrollment unit, state Special Education",
      "rounding": "Exact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
      "uncertainty": {
        "description": "An exact difference of two reported ratios.",
        "kind": "none_quantified"
      },
      "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
      "value_id": "value-special-education-change"
    },
    {
      "definition_id": "def-program",
      "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in each year.",
      "display": "397.47",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-program-contributions"
      ],
      "exact": {
        "denominator": "2000000000000",
        "numerator": "794930508544251"
      },
      "label": "Change per enrollment unit, Districtwide support",
      "rounding": "Exact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
      "uncertainty": {
        "description": "An exact difference of two reported ratios.",
        "kind": "none_quantified"
      },
      "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
      "value_id": "value-districtwide-change"
    },
    {
      "definition_id": "def-program",
      "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in each year.",
      "display": "-314.27",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-program-contributions"
      ],
      "exact": {
        "denominator": "12500000000000",
        "numerator": "-3928338068185353"
      },
      "label": "Change per enrollment unit, ESSER III",
      "rounding": "Exact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
      "uncertainty": {
        "description": "An exact difference of two reported ratios.",
        "kind": "none_quantified"
      },
      "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
      "value_id": "value-esser-three-change"
    },
    {
      "definition_id": "def-program",
      "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in each year.",
      "display": "-251.63",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-program-contributions"
      ],
      "exact": {
        "denominator": "12500000000000",
        "numerator": "-3145396627141151"
      },
      "label": "Change per enrollment unit, ESSER II",
      "rounding": "Exact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
      "uncertainty": {
        "description": "An exact difference of two reported ratios.",
        "kind": "none_quantified"
      },
      "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
      "value_id": "value-esser-two-change"
    },
    {
      "definition_id": "def-program",
      "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in each year.",
      "display": "-188.36",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-program-contributions"
      ],
      "exact": {
        "denominator": "5000000000000",
        "numerator": "-941792680599333"
      },
      "label": "Change per enrollment unit, SLFRF enrollment stabilization",
      "rounding": "Exact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
      "uncertainty": {
        "description": "An exact difference of two reported ratios.",
        "kind": "none_quantified"
      },
      "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
      "value_id": "value-slfrf-change"
    }
  ],
  "would_change": "A revision by OSPI to either year's program-level totals."
}