School spending ยท Edition 0002
Comparing three starting years
The nominal change and the change after each of the two consumer price indexes, measured from 2018-19, from 2019-20 and from 2021-22, every window ending 2024-25.
Renderings of this chart
- The same change from three starting years
- The three starting years, detached copy
- The three starting years, phone rendering
Renderings of the same plotted data; not separate research findings or chart families.
Data and reproduction recipe
Exactly the nine percentage changes drawn in the starting-year figure, three for each starting school year, in plotted order.
Published recipe files are provided as downloads. This presentation reuses the published assets without rerunning the underlying research.
| Column | Label | Unit | Representation |
|---|---|---|---|
| window | Comparison | label | text |
| change_percent | Change | percent | decimal |
Published plotted rows
| window | change_percent |
|---|---|
| From 2018-19 in dollars reported | 36.041000915709 |
| From 2018-19 after U.S. prices | 8.258478320688 |
| From 2018-19 after Seattle-area prices | 4.481932082014 |
| From 2019-20 in dollars reported | 32.134527099108 |
| From 2019-20 after U.S. prices | 6.683230012337 |
| From 2019-20 after Seattle-area prices | 3.293080052908 |
| From 2021-22 in dollars reported | 12.533592583495 |
| From 2021-22 after U.S. prices | 0.773922350855 |
| From 2021-22 after Seattle-area prices | -1.527871273568 |
Findings that declare these chart artifacts
Edition qualifications
- limits inference. The denominator is OSPI financial-summary enrollment, which mixes full-time-equivalent K-12 enrollment with birth-to-five special-education headcounts and various institutional programs, so it is not a count of individual K-12 students.
- limits inference. CPI-U measures general consumer prices, not the prices schools themselves pay for staff, materials or services, and no school input-cost index is used here.
- limits scope. Each comparison uses only its two endpoint school years; the years between them, including 2020-21, are not examined, even though the workbook holds other years.
- limits inference. Nothing here establishes the causes of these changes, or speaks to adequacy, efficiency, educational quality or district reserve levels.
- unresolved evidence. OSPI and BLS may revise these files later; every figure here is pinned to the specific workbook and index vintage captured on 2026-09-11.
- limits scope. The selected relief programs are an explicit choice of six OSPI codes, including program 23, and differ from OSPI's own five-code CARES grouping.
- limits scope. None of the three starting years used for comparison, 2018-19, 2019-20 or 2021-22, is privileged over the others, and the school years between them are not compared.
- unresolved evidence. OSPI's own printed Section One table lists 1,088,272 enrollment units for 2024-25, versus 1,088,261.99 in the captured workbook, a difference of 10.01 units; this article uses the workbook throughout.
Citation
Published figure:
https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/assets/figures/base-year-windows.svgSource data SHA-256: 889876e77151582edc1b137f6fce24656201ef9c8ddd96bfb6fcb54a9e71a177
Figure SHA-256: 20c91b93a8b0c6496555cb345f765244bea52debd296493047bd21a1261be04c
Complete original record
{
"record_type": "published_chart_family_export",
"source_edition": {
"url": "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/",
"release_url": "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/release.json",
"release_id": "q-wa-school-spending@0002",
"edition": "0002",
"published_at": "2026-09-12T17:00:00Z",
"evidence_cutoff_at": "2026-09-11T06:04:25Z",
"release_sha256": "d27aa7c29adcc804fa1b7e09d90321134bad4fbcdeb0ee3beff6363d47b8235c",
"release_bytes": 103569,
"retrieved_at_utc": "2026-09-22T00:11:36.402249+00:00",
"scope": "Inventory of an existing published release. No research calculations or source checks were rerun.",
"local_release_url": "/research/school-spending/0002/release.json"
},
"local_url": "/research/school-spending/0002/plots/artifact-base-year-figure/",
"published_figure_url": "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/assets/figures/base-year-windows.svg",
"chart_family": {
"family_id": "artifact-base-year-figure",
"label": "The same change from three starting years",
"primary_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-figure",
"figure_artifact_ids": [
"artifact-base-year-figure",
"artifact-base-year-figure-detached",
"artifact-base-year-figure-narrow"
],
"data_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-data",
"recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-recipe",
"bindings": [
{
"arguments": [
"wide",
"0002",
"September 12, 2026",
"https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
],
"data_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-data",
"figure_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-figure",
"recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-recipe"
},
{
"arguments": [
"png",
"0002",
"September 12, 2026",
"https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
],
"data_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-data",
"figure_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-figure-detached",
"recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-recipe"
},
{
"arguments": [
"narrow",
"0002",
"September 12, 2026",
"https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
],
"data_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-data",
"figure_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-figure-narrow",
"recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-recipe"
}
],
"finding_ids_declaring_family_artifacts": [
"f-base-year-window"
],
"panel_occurrence_ids": [
"f-base-year-window/p-base-years"
],
"variant_semantics": "Renderings of the same plotted data; not separate research findings or chart families."
},
"original_artifact": {
"alt": "Bar chart of nine percentage changes, three for each of three starting school years.",
"artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-figure",
"bytes": 5725,
"caption": "The nominal change and the change after each of the two consumer price indexes, measured from 2018-19, from 2019-20 and from 2021-22, every window ending 2024-25.",
"evidence_ids": [],
"finding_ids": [
"f-base-year-window"
],
"kind": "figure",
"label": "The same change from three starting years",
"license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
"media_type": "image/svg+xml",
"path": "assets/figures/base-year-windows.svg",
"reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
"sha256": "20c91b93a8b0c6496555cb345f765244bea52debd296493047bd21a1261be04c"
},
"original_variant_artifacts": [
{
"alt": "Bar chart of nine percentage changes, three for each of three starting school years.",
"artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-figure",
"bytes": 5725,
"caption": "The nominal change and the change after each of the two consumer price indexes, measured from 2018-19, from 2019-20 and from 2021-22, every window ending 2024-25.",
"evidence_ids": [],
"finding_ids": [
"f-base-year-window"
],
"kind": "figure",
"label": "The same change from three starting years",
"license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
"media_type": "image/svg+xml",
"path": "assets/figures/base-year-windows.svg",
"reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
"sha256": "20c91b93a8b0c6496555cb345f765244bea52debd296493047bd21a1261be04c"
},
{
"alt": "Bar chart of the nine percentage changes with its title, date and source printed on the image.",
"artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-figure-detached",
"bytes": 152884,
"caption": "The same nine percentage changes as a raster copy carrying its own title, date, qualification and source address.",
"evidence_ids": [],
"finding_ids": [],
"kind": "figure",
"label": "The three starting years, detached copy",
"license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
"media_type": "image/png",
"path": "assets/figures/base-year-windows.png",
"reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
"sha256": "f9fdf545f885b24344a0c4f1be213809fcce1eac83c784a7e4aab5a9ef10e3a5"
},
{
"alt": "Bar chart of the nine percentage changes, drawn for a narrow screen.",
"artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-figure-narrow",
"bytes": 7285,
"caption": "The same nine percentage changes drawn for a narrow screen, with readable labels.",
"evidence_ids": [],
"finding_ids": [],
"kind": "figure",
"label": "The three starting years, phone rendering",
"license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
"media_type": "image/svg+xml",
"path": "assets/figures/base-year-windows-narrow.svg",
"reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
"sha256": "430c353001bc49c7ce800229f55a17cf2bacc97c292eaff546f82947678005e4"
}
],
"original_data_artifact": {
"alt": "Table of the nine percentage changes drawn in the starting-year figure.",
"artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-data",
"bytes": 470,
"caption": "Exactly the nine percentage changes drawn in the starting-year figure, three for each starting school year, in plotted order.",
"data_columns": [
{
"definition_id": "def-per-unit",
"key": "window",
"label": "Comparison",
"representation": "text",
"unit": "label"
},
{
"definition_id": "def-per-unit",
"key": "change_percent",
"label": "Change",
"representation": "decimal",
"unit": "percent"
}
],
"evidence_ids": [],
"finding_ids": [
"f-base-year-window"
],
"kind": "data",
"label": "Plotted starting-year comparisons",
"license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
"media_type": "text/csv",
"path": "assets/data/base-year-windows.csv",
"reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
"sha256": "889876e77151582edc1b137f6fce24656201ef9c8ddd96bfb6fcb54a9e71a177"
},
"original_recipe_artifact": {
"alt": "Python source that rebuilds the starting-year figure.",
"artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-recipe",
"bytes": 4133,
"caption": "Rebuilds the starting-year figure in each rendering from its plotted rows.",
"evidence_ids": [],
"finding_ids": [],
"kind": "calculation_code",
"label": "Starting-year figure recipe",
"license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
"media_type": "text/x-python",
"path": "assets/recipes/figure_base_years.py",
"reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
"sha256": "54e0eb3348875ecdc7430bbfcf552c5661d065ce31f5ecc0aeb920e8eecb81f5"
},
"original_binding_records": [
{
"arguments": [
"wide",
"0002",
"September 12, 2026",
"https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
],
"data_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-data",
"figure_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-figure",
"recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-recipe"
},
{
"arguments": [
"png",
"0002",
"September 12, 2026",
"https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
],
"data_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-data",
"figure_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-figure-detached",
"recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-recipe"
},
{
"arguments": [
"narrow",
"0002",
"September 12, 2026",
"https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
],
"data_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-data",
"figure_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-figure-narrow",
"recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-recipe"
}
],
"original_associated_findings": [
{
"argument": {
"counterevidence_ids": [
"e-relief-absent-early"
],
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1819",
"e-expenditures-1920",
"e-enrollment-1819",
"e-enrollment-1920"
],
"panels": [
{
"artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-figure",
"data_artifact_id": "artifact-base-year-data",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1819",
"e-cpi-observations"
],
"panel_id": "p-base-years",
"qualification_ids": [
"qual-window-choice",
"qual-consumer-prices"
],
"question": "Does the size of the change depend on the year you start counting from?",
"takeaway": "Starting from 2018-19 gives 36.0% nominal (8.3% after U.S. inflation); from 2019-20, 32.1% (6.7%); from 2021-22, 12.5% (0.8%). All three windows end in 2024-25."
},
{
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1819",
"e-enrollment-1819"
],
"panel_id": "p-statewide-series",
"qualification_ids": [
"qual-enrollment-measure"
],
"question": "What does the four-year spending and enrollment table show?",
"takeaway": "Spending, enrollment and spending per enrollment unit for 2018-19, 2019-20, 2021-22 and 2024-25, as read from the captured OSPI workbook."
}
],
"premise_finding_ids": [
"f-nominal-growth",
"f-inflation-adjusted"
],
"reasoning": "The same ratio is formed from a different starting school year. Because 2021-22 carried about a billion dollars of federal relief spending, it is a high starting point, so a window that begins before that spending arrived gives a larger change.",
"unresolved_alternatives": [
"None of these three windows is privileged. A different starting year, or the school years between them, would give another figure.",
"No relief-excluded measure exists for the two earlier windows, because the six program codes carry no value in those columns."
]
},
"artifact_ids": [
"artifact-base-year-figure",
"artifact-base-year-data",
"artifact-series-data",
"artifact-series-verification",
"artifact-growth-recipe"
],
"calculation_ids": [
"calc-base-year-windows"
],
"check_ids": [
"check-series-verification",
"check-statewide-arithmetic",
"check-cpi-window"
],
"check_scope": "All four school years were read from the captured workbook and each year's totals equal both OSPI's own total row and the sum of that year's reporting rows to the cent. Every window percentage was recomputed exactly from those totals and the four index means.",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1819",
"e-expenditures-1920",
"e-enrollment-1819",
"e-enrollment-1920",
"e-cpi-observations"
],
"finding_id": "f-base-year-window",
"kind": "calculation",
"material_qualifications": [
{
"effect": "limits_scope",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1819",
"e-expenditures-1920",
"e-relief-absent-early"
],
"qualification_id": "qual-window-choice",
"text": "None of the three starting years used for comparison, 2018-19, 2019-20 or 2021-22, is privileged over the others, and the school years between them are not compared."
},
{
"effect": "limits_inference",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-enrollment-definition"
],
"qualification_id": "qual-enrollment-measure",
"text": "The denominator is OSPI financial-summary enrollment, which mixes full-time-equivalent K-12 enrollment with birth-to-five special-education headcounts and various institutional programs, so it is not a count of individual K-12 students."
},
{
"effect": "limits_inference",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-cpi-observations"
],
"qualification_id": "qual-consumer-prices",
"text": "CPI-U measures general consumer prices, not the prices schools themselves pay for staff, materials or services, and no school input-cost index is used here."
},
{
"effect": "limits_inference",
"evidence_ids": [],
"qualification_id": "qual-no-causes",
"text": "Nothing here establishes the causes of these changes, or speaks to adequacy, efficiency, educational quality or district reserve levels."
},
{
"effect": "unresolved_evidence",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-2425"
],
"qualification_id": "qual-source-vintage",
"text": "OSPI and BLS may revise these files later; every figure here is pinned to the specific workbook and index vintage captured on 2026-09-11."
}
],
"reader_context": [
{
"answer": "Because the size of the measured change depends on which school year the comparison starts from; this article compares three starting years, all ending in 2024-25, without examining the years in between.",
"context_id": "rc-base-year",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1819",
"e-relief-absent-early"
],
"question": "Why do the same figures produce three different percentages?",
"status": "supported",
"visible_near": "The first statement that the result depends on the starting year."
}
],
"scope_id": "scope-wa-k12",
"state": "supported",
"text": "Starting from 2018-19, the nominal change to 2024-25 is 36.0%, or 8.3% after U.S. inflation and 4.5% after Seattle-area inflation. Starting from 2019-20, it is 32.1% nominal, 6.7% and 3.3%. Starting from 2021-22, it is 12.5% nominal, 0.8% and -1.5%.",
"title": "The size of the change depends on which year the comparison starts from",
"values": [
{
"definition_id": "def-general-fund",
"denominator": "The 313 of 326 listed reporting entities that report a General Fund expenditure in 2018-19.",
"display": "$15,910,940,924.66",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1819"
],
"exact": {
"decimal": "15910940924.66"
},
"label": "General Fund expenditures, 2018-19",
"rounding": "Rounded half-up to the cent.",
"uncertainty": {
"description": "A reported total. OSPI may revise the file; this edition pins the captured vintage.",
"kind": "none_quantified"
},
"unit": "dollars",
"value_id": "value-expenditures-1819"
},
{
"definition_id": "def-enrollment",
"denominator": "The 323 of 326 listed reporting entities that carry an enrollment value in 2018-19.",
"display": "1,117,394.73",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-enrollment-1819"
],
"exact": {
"decimal": "1117394.73"
},
"label": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment, 2018-19",
"rounding": "Rounded half-up to two places.",
"uncertainty": {
"description": "A reported total under the same enrollment measure as the later years.",
"kind": "none_quantified"
},
"unit": "enrollment units",
"value_id": "value-enrollment-1819"
},
{
"definition_id": "def-general-fund",
"denominator": "The 311 of 326 listed reporting entities that report a General Fund expenditure in 2019-20.",
"display": "$16,529,878,455.73",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1920"
],
"exact": {
"decimal": "16529878455.73"
},
"label": "General Fund expenditures, 2019-20",
"rounding": "Rounded half-up to the cent.",
"uncertainty": {
"description": "A reported total. OSPI may revise the file; this edition pins the captured vintage.",
"kind": "none_quantified"
},
"unit": "dollars",
"value_id": "value-expenditures-1920"
},
{
"definition_id": "def-enrollment",
"denominator": "The 319 of 326 listed reporting entities that carry an enrollment value in 2019-20.",
"display": "1,127,526.90",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-enrollment-1920"
],
"exact": {
"decimal": "1127526.90"
},
"label": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment, 2019-20",
"rounding": "Rounded half-up to two places.",
"uncertainty": {
"description": "A reported total under the same enrollment measure as the later years.",
"kind": "none_quantified"
},
"unit": "enrollment units",
"value_id": "value-enrollment-1920"
},
{
"definition_id": "def-per-unit",
"denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in 2018-19.",
"display": "$14,239.32",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1819",
"e-enrollment-1819"
],
"exact": {
"denominator": "111739473",
"numerator": "1591094092466"
},
"label": "Spending per enrollment unit, 2018-19",
"rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
"uncertainty": {
"description": "An exact ratio of two reported totals.",
"kind": "none_quantified"
},
"unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
"value_id": "value-per-unit-1819"
},
{
"definition_id": "def-per-unit",
"denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in 2019-20.",
"display": "$14,660.30",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1920",
"e-enrollment-1920"
],
"exact": {
"denominator": "112752690",
"numerator": "1652987845573"
},
"label": "Spending per enrollment unit, 2019-20",
"rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
"uncertainty": {
"description": "An exact ratio of two reported totals.",
"kind": "none_quantified"
},
"unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
"value_id": "value-per-unit-1920"
},
{
"definition_id": "def-per-unit",
"denominator": "Spending per enrollment unit in 2018-19.",
"display": "36.0%",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1819",
"e-enrollment-1819",
"e-expenditures-2425",
"e-enrollment-2425"
],
"exact": {
"denominator": "86576361167214658367",
"numerator": "3120298712106346491400"
},
"label": "Change from 2018-19 to 2024-25, in dollars reported",
"rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to one place.",
"uncertainty": {
"description": "An exact ratio of two reported totals; no sampling uncertainty applies.",
"kind": "none_quantified"
},
"unit": "percent",
"value_id": "value-nominal-from-1819"
},
{
"definition_id": "def-real-change",
"denominator": "Spending per enrollment unit in 2018-19.",
"display": "8.3%",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1819",
"e-enrollment-1819",
"e-expenditures-2425",
"e-enrollment-2425",
"e-cpi-observations"
],
"exact": {
"denominator": "5527121473276151004807647",
"numerator": "45645612862859083770525895"
},
"label": "Change from 2018-19 to 2024-25, after U.S. city-average consumer prices",
"rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to one place.",
"uncertainty": {
"description": "Exact arithmetic over reported index values; the index measures consumer prices, not school input prices.",
"kind": "none_quantified"
},
"unit": "percent",
"value_id": "value-real-us-from-1819"
},
{
"definition_id": "def-real-change",
"denominator": "Spending per enrollment unit in 2018-19.",
"display": "4.5%",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1819",
"e-enrollment-1819",
"e-expenditures-2425",
"e-enrollment-2425",
"e-cpi-observations"
],
"exact": {
"denominator": "186798109194355186253881237",
"numerator": "837216438457787938509136700"
},
"label": "Change from 2018-19 to 2024-25, after Seattle-area consumer prices",
"rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to one place.",
"uncertainty": {
"description": "Exact arithmetic over six bimonthly observations per window.",
"kind": "none_quantified"
},
"unit": "percent",
"value_id": "value-real-seattle-from-1819"
},
{
"definition_id": "def-per-unit",
"denominator": "Spending per enrollment unit in 2019-20.",
"display": "32.1%",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1920",
"e-enrollment-1920",
"e-expenditures-2425",
"e-enrollment-2425"
],
"exact": {
"denominator": "179888384226908567027",
"numerator": "5780628157754271883300"
},
"label": "Change from 2019-20 to 2024-25, in dollars reported",
"rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to one place.",
"uncertainty": {
"description": "An exact ratio of two reported totals; no sampling uncertainty applies.",
"kind": "none_quantified"
},
"unit": "percent",
"value_id": "value-nominal-from-1920"
},
{
"definition_id": "def-real-change",
"denominator": "Spending per enrollment unit in 2019-20.",
"display": "6.7%",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1920",
"e-enrollment-1920",
"e-expenditures-2425",
"e-enrollment-2425",
"e-cpi-observations"
],
"exact": {
"denominator": "11484254337430069827570707",
"numerator": "76751913257220132601144300"
},
"label": "Change from 2019-20 to 2024-25, after U.S. city-average consumer prices",
"rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to one place.",
"uncertainty": {
"description": "Exact arithmetic over reported index values; the index measures consumer prices, not school input prices.",
"kind": "none_quantified"
},
"unit": "percent",
"value_id": "value-real-us-from-1920"
},
{
"definition_id": "def-real-change",
"denominator": "Spending per enrollment unit in 2019-20.",
"display": "3.3%",
"evidence_ids": [
"e-expenditures-1920",
"e-enrollment-1920",
"e-expenditures-2425",
"e-enrollment-2425",
"e-cpi-observations"
],
"exact": {
"denominator": "388129156580204420211692497",
"numerator": "1278140383486299449950682300"
},
"label": "Change from 2019-20 to 2024-25, after Seattle-area consumer prices",
"rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to one place.",
"uncertainty": {
"description": "Exact arithmetic over six bimonthly observations per window.",
"kind": "none_quantified"
},
"unit": "percent",
"value_id": "value-real-seattle-from-1920"
}
],
"would_change": "Comparing against a different starting school year than the three examined here."
}
]
}