{
  "record_type": "published_chart_family_export",
  "source_edition": {
    "url": "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/",
    "release_url": "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/release.json",
    "release_id": "q-wa-school-spending@0002",
    "edition": "0002",
    "published_at": "2026-09-12T17:00:00Z",
    "evidence_cutoff_at": "2026-09-11T06:04:25Z",
    "release_sha256": "d27aa7c29adcc804fa1b7e09d90321134bad4fbcdeb0ee3beff6363d47b8235c",
    "release_bytes": 103569,
    "retrieved_at_utc": "2026-09-22T00:11:36.402249+00:00",
    "scope": "Inventory of an existing published release. No research calculations or source checks were rerun.",
    "local_release_url": "/research/school-spending/0002/release.json"
  },
  "local_url": "/research/school-spending/0002/plots/artifact-programs-figure/",
  "published_figure_url": "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/assets/figures/program-contributions.svg",
  "chart_family": {
    "family_id": "artifact-programs-figure",
    "label": "Programs behind the change",
    "primary_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-figure",
    "figure_artifact_ids": [
      "artifact-programs-figure",
      "artifact-programs-figure-narrow"
    ],
    "data_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-data",
    "recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-recipe",
    "bindings": [
      {
        "arguments": [
          "wide",
          "0002",
          "September 12, 2026",
          "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
        ],
        "data_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-data",
        "figure_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-figure",
        "recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-recipe"
      },
      {
        "arguments": [
          "narrow",
          "0002",
          "September 12, 2026",
          "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
        ],
        "data_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-data",
        "figure_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-figure-narrow",
        "recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-recipe"
      }
    ],
    "finding_ids_declaring_family_artifacts": [
      "f-relief-exclusion",
      "f-program-mix"
    ],
    "panel_occurrence_ids": [
      "f-program-mix/p-program-mix"
    ],
    "variant_semantics": "Renderings of the same plotted data; not separate research findings or chart families."
  },
  "original_artifact": {
    "alt": "Bar chart of program changes in dollars per enrollment unit.",
    "artifact_id": "artifact-programs-figure",
    "bytes": 10971,
    "caption": "Change in dollars per enrollment unit for the eight largest increases and six largest decreases by program.",
    "evidence_ids": [],
    "finding_ids": [
      "f-program-mix",
      "f-relief-exclusion"
    ],
    "kind": "figure",
    "label": "Programs behind the change",
    "license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
    "media_type": "image/svg+xml",
    "path": "assets/figures/program-contributions.svg",
    "reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
    "sha256": "428ab6ddba877607f376e4ef0ef437665aaf15b8449888a3155f1c6755680b27"
  },
  "original_variant_artifacts": [
    {
      "alt": "Bar chart of program changes in dollars per enrollment unit.",
      "artifact_id": "artifact-programs-figure",
      "bytes": 10971,
      "caption": "Change in dollars per enrollment unit for the eight largest increases and six largest decreases by program.",
      "evidence_ids": [],
      "finding_ids": [
        "f-program-mix",
        "f-relief-exclusion"
      ],
      "kind": "figure",
      "label": "Programs behind the change",
      "license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
      "media_type": "image/svg+xml",
      "path": "assets/figures/program-contributions.svg",
      "reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
      "sha256": "428ab6ddba877607f376e4ef0ef437665aaf15b8449888a3155f1c6755680b27"
    },
    {
      "alt": "Bar chart of program changes, drawn for a narrow screen.",
      "artifact_id": "artifact-programs-figure-narrow",
      "bytes": 9851,
      "caption": "The same program rows drawn for a narrow screen, with readable labels.",
      "evidence_ids": [],
      "finding_ids": [],
      "kind": "figure",
      "label": "The program rows, phone rendering",
      "license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
      "media_type": "image/svg+xml",
      "path": "assets/figures/program-contributions-narrow.svg",
      "reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
      "sha256": "c2c058eb5d3bb2e4060e0fcefa0ab4f606b9c7e8de05a2434d75ebac0d72c810"
    }
  ],
  "original_data_artifact": {
    "alt": "Table of program changes in dollars per enrollment unit drawn in that figure.",
    "artifact_id": "artifact-programs-data",
    "bytes": 501,
    "caption": "Exactly the fourteen program rows drawn in the program-contribution figure, in plotted\n     order.",
    "data_columns": [
      {
        "definition_id": "def-program",
        "key": "program",
        "label": "Program",
        "representation": "text",
        "unit": "label"
      },
      {
        "definition_id": "def-per-unit",
        "key": "pp_change_dollars",
        "label": "Change per enrollment unit",
        "representation": "decimal",
        "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit"
      }
    ],
    "evidence_ids": [
      "e-program-contributions"
    ],
    "finding_ids": [
      "f-program-mix",
      "f-relief-exclusion"
    ],
    "kind": "data",
    "label": "Plotted program contributions",
    "license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
    "media_type": "text/csv",
    "path": "assets/data/program-contributions.csv",
    "reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
    "sha256": "0540003dc75bf482d2c5794ddbcb9830c5b8db16655906deb73f59a17ab7e4ba"
  },
  "original_recipe_artifact": {
    "alt": "Python source that rebuilds the program-contribution figure.",
    "artifact_id": "artifact-programs-recipe",
    "bytes": 2397,
    "caption": "Rebuilds the program-contribution figure in both renderings from its plotted rows.",
    "evidence_ids": [],
    "finding_ids": [],
    "kind": "calculation_code",
    "label": "Program-contribution figure recipe",
    "license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
    "media_type": "text/x-python",
    "path": "assets/recipes/figure_programs.py",
    "reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
    "sha256": "22ebff55c53eefd326ab92b2f8411f79c5e6f9d433781a84f910f80d981e8c29"
  },
  "original_binding_records": [
    {
      "arguments": [
        "wide",
        "0002",
        "September 12, 2026",
        "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
      ],
      "data_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-data",
      "figure_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-figure",
      "recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-recipe"
    },
    {
      "arguments": [
        "narrow",
        "0002",
        "September 12, 2026",
        "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
      ],
      "data_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-data",
      "figure_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-figure-narrow",
      "recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-recipe"
    }
  ],
  "original_associated_findings": [
    {
      "argument": {
        "counterevidence_ids": [],
        "evidence_ids": [
          "e-relief-programs"
        ],
        "panels": [
          {
            "evidence_ids": [
              "e-relief-programs"
            ],
            "panel_id": "p-per-unit",
            "qualification_ids": [
              "qual-relief-selection"
            ],
            "question": "What are the actual dollar figures per enrollment unit behind the percentages?",
            "takeaway": "Spending per enrollment unit rose from $17,213.81 to $19,371.31; excluding relief spending, from $16,267.05 to $19,368.10."
          }
        ],
        "premise_finding_ids": [
          "f-nominal-growth"
        ],
        "reasoning": "Removing the same six programs from both years' numerators, while keeping each year's enrollment denominator, isolates the change outside that spending.",
        "unresolved_alternatives": [
          "OSPI's own five-code CARES grouping excludes program 23 and would give a different figure."
        ]
      },
      "artifact_ids": [
        "artifact-program-expenditures",
        "artifact-programs-figure",
        "artifact-programs-data"
      ],
      "calculation_ids": [
        "calc-statewide-growth"
      ],
      "check_ids": [
        "check-source-verification",
        "check-statewide-arithmetic"
      ],
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-relief-programs",
        "e-program-codes",
        "e-cpi-observations"
      ],
      "finding_id": "f-relief-exclusion",
      "kind": "calculation",
      "material_qualifications": [
        {
          "effect": "limits_scope",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-relief-programs",
            "e-program-codes"
          ],
          "qualification_id": "qual-relief-selection",
          "text": "The selected relief programs are an explicit choice of six OSPI codes, including program 23, and differ from OSPI's own five-code CARES grouping."
        },
        {
          "effect": "limits_inference",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-enrollment-definition"
          ],
          "qualification_id": "qual-enrollment-measure",
          "text": "The denominator is OSPI financial-summary enrollment, which mixes full-time-equivalent K-12 enrollment with birth-to-five special-education headcounts and various institutional programs, so it is not a count of individual K-12 students."
        },
        {
          "effect": "limits_inference",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-cpi-observations"
          ],
          "qualification_id": "qual-consumer-prices",
          "text": "CPI-U measures general consumer prices, not the prices schools themselves pay for staff, materials or services, and no school input-cost index is used here."
        },
        {
          "effect": "limits_inference",
          "evidence_ids": [],
          "qualification_id": "qual-no-causes",
          "text": "Nothing here establishes the causes of these changes, or speaks to adequacy, efficiency, educational quality or district reserve levels."
        }
      ],
      "reader_context": [
        {
          "answer": "Six OSPI program codes: SLFRF enrollment stabilization, ESSER II, ESSER III, ESSER III learning loss, other CARES Act spending, and ARP-IDEA special education.",
          "context_id": "rc-relief-programs",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-program-codes",
            "e-relief-programs"
          ],
          "question": "What counts as 'federal COVID relief spending' here?",
          "status": "supported",
          "visible_near": "The first mention of the selected relief programs."
        }
      ],
      "scope_id": "scope-wa-k12",
      "state": "supported",
      "text": "Selected federal relief program spending was $1,015,767,886.56 in 2021-22 and $3,491,983.06 in 2024-25. Excluding it, the nominal change is 19.1%, the change after U.S. inflation is 6.6%, and the change after Seattle-area inflation is 4.2%. No relief-excluded measure exists for the 2018-19 or 2019-20 windows because those columns carry no relief-program values.",
      "title": "Excluding the six selected federal relief programs, the change is 19.1% in dollars reported",
      "values": [
        {
          "definition_id": "def-relief-programs",
          "denominator": "The six selected OSPI programs in 2021-22.",
          "display": "$1,015,767,886.56",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-relief-programs"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "decimal": "1015767886.56"
          },
          "label": "Selected relief-program spending, 2021-22",
          "rounding": "Rounded half-up to the cent.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "A reported total under the stated program selection.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "dollars",
          "value_id": "value-relief-2122"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-relief-programs",
          "denominator": "The six selected OSPI programs in 2024-25.",
          "display": "$3,491,983.06",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-relief-programs"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "decimal": "3491983.06"
          },
          "label": "Selected relief-program spending, 2024-25",
          "rounding": "Rounded half-up to the cent.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "A reported total under the stated program selection.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "dollars",
          "value_id": "value-relief-2425"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-relief-programs",
          "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in 2021-22.",
          "display": "$16,267.05",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-expenditures-2122",
            "e-enrollment-2122",
            "e-relief-programs"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "denominator": "11921053",
            "numerator": "193920372084"
          },
          "label": "Spending per enrollment unit excluding the selected relief programs, 2021-22",
          "rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "An exact ratio under the stated program selection.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
          "value_id": "value-per-unit-excluding-relief-2122"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-relief-programs",
          "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in 2024-25.",
          "display": "$19,368.10",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-expenditures-2425",
            "e-enrollment-2425",
            "e-relief-programs"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "denominator": "108826199",
            "numerator": "2107757187488"
          },
          "label": "Spending per enrollment unit excluding the selected relief programs, 2024-25",
          "rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "An exact ratio under the stated program selection.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
          "value_id": "value-per-unit-excluding-relief-2425"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-relief-programs",
          "denominator": "Spending per enrollment unit in 2021-22, excluding the same six programs.",
          "display": "19.1%",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-relief-programs"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "denominator": "5275904250641857179",
            "numerator": "100576703515198903700"
          },
          "label": "Change excluding the selected relief programs",
          "rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to one place.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "An exact ratio under the stated program selection.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "percent",
          "value_id": "value-growth-excluding-relief"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-real-change",
          "denominator": "Spending per enrollment unit in 2021-22 excluding the same six programs, divided by the ratio of the two U.S. index means.",
          "display": "6.6%",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-relief-programs",
            "e-cpi-observations"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "denominator": "1010457009795680412493617",
            "numerator": "6690615075953635816632700"
          },
          "label": "Change excluding the selected relief programs, after U.S. city-average consumer prices",
          "rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to one place.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "Exact arithmetic under the stated program selection over reported index values.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "percent",
          "value_id": "value-real-growth-us-excluding-relief"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-real-change",
          "denominator": "Spending per enrollment unit in 2021-22 excluding the same six programs, divided by the ratio of the two Seattle-area index means.",
          "display": "4.2%",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-relief-programs",
            "e-cpi-observations"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "denominator": "11383349046131628109839369",
            "numerator": "47650915816001148443079100"
          },
          "label": "Change excluding the selected relief programs, after Seattle-area consumer prices",
          "rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to one place.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "Exact arithmetic under the stated program selection over reported index values.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "percent",
          "value_id": "value-real-growth-seattle-excluding-relief"
        }
      ],
      "would_change": "A different selection of relief program codes than the six used here."
    },
    {
      "argument": {
        "counterevidence_ids": [],
        "evidence_ids": [
          "e-program-contributions"
        ],
        "panels": [
          {
            "artifact_id": "artifact-programs-figure",
            "data_artifact_id": "artifact-programs-data",
            "evidence_ids": [
              "e-program-contributions"
            ],
            "panel_id": "p-program-mix",
            "qualification_ids": [
              "qual-relief-selection",
              "qual-enrollment-measure"
            ],
            "question": "Which programs drove the change in spending per enrollment unit?",
            "takeaway": "The chart shows the eight largest per-unit increases, led by Basic Education and Special Ed, and the six largest decreases, led by ESSER III and ESSER II; selected bars need not sum to the statewide change."
          }
        ],
        "premise_finding_ids": [
          "f-nominal-growth"
        ],
        "reasoning": "Each program's contribution is its own spending per enrollment unit in the later year minus the same ratio in the earlier year.",
        "unresolved_alternatives": [
          "Only the largest increases and decreases are drawn, so the selected bars need not sum to the statewide change."
        ]
      },
      "artifact_ids": [
        "artifact-programs-figure",
        "artifact-programs-data",
        "artifact-program-expenditures"
      ],
      "calculation_ids": [],
      "check_ids": [
        "check-source-verification"
      ],
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-program-contributions",
        "e-program-codes"
      ],
      "finding_id": "f-program-mix",
      "kind": "observation",
      "material_qualifications": [
        {
          "effect": "limits_scope",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-relief-programs",
            "e-program-codes"
          ],
          "qualification_id": "qual-relief-selection",
          "text": "The selected relief programs are an explicit choice of six OSPI codes, including program 23, and differ from OSPI's own five-code CARES grouping."
        },
        {
          "effect": "limits_inference",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-enrollment-definition"
          ],
          "qualification_id": "qual-enrollment-measure",
          "text": "The denominator is OSPI financial-summary enrollment, which mixes full-time-equivalent K-12 enrollment with birth-to-five special-education headcounts and various institutional programs, so it is not a count of individual K-12 students."
        },
        {
          "effect": "limits_inference",
          "evidence_ids": [],
          "qualification_id": "qual-no-causes",
          "text": "Nothing here establishes the causes of these changes, or speaks to adequacy, efficiency, educational quality or district reserve levels."
        }
      ],
      "reader_context": [
        {
          "answer": "No. Of 326 listed reporting entities, 318 reported General Fund expenditures in 2021-22 and 319 in 2024-25; 319 and 326 carried an enrollment value in those years.",
          "context_id": "rc-program-coverage",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-program-contributions"
          ],
          "question": "Does every district report every year?",
          "status": "supported",
          "visible_near": "The program chart."
        }
      ],
      "scope_id": "scope-wa-k12",
      "state": "supported",
      "text": "Per enrollment unit, the largest increases came from Basic Education (+$977.79), Special Ed state funding (+$809.37) and districtwide support (+$397.47). The largest decreases came from ESSER III (-$314.27), ESSER II (-$251.63) and SLFRF enrollment stabilization (-$188.36). These selected program bars do not need to sum to the statewide change.",
      "title": "Basic Education and Special Ed had the largest per-unit spending increases",
      "values": [
        {
          "definition_id": "def-program",
          "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in each year.",
          "display": "977.79",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-program-contributions"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "denominator": "625000000000",
            "numerator": "611121524074831"
          },
          "label": "Change per enrollment unit, Basic Education",
          "rounding": "Exact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "An exact difference of two reported ratios.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
          "value_id": "value-basic-education-change"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-program",
          "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in each year.",
          "display": "809.37",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-program-contributions"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "denominator": "2000000000000",
            "numerator": "1618737993278417"
          },
          "label": "Change per enrollment unit, state Special Education",
          "rounding": "Exact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "An exact difference of two reported ratios.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
          "value_id": "value-special-education-change"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-program",
          "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in each year.",
          "display": "397.47",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-program-contributions"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "denominator": "2000000000000",
            "numerator": "794930508544251"
          },
          "label": "Change per enrollment unit, Districtwide support",
          "rounding": "Exact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "An exact difference of two reported ratios.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
          "value_id": "value-districtwide-change"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-program",
          "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in each year.",
          "display": "-314.27",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-program-contributions"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "denominator": "12500000000000",
            "numerator": "-3928338068185353"
          },
          "label": "Change per enrollment unit, ESSER III",
          "rounding": "Exact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "An exact difference of two reported ratios.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
          "value_id": "value-esser-three-change"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-program",
          "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in each year.",
          "display": "-251.63",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-program-contributions"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "denominator": "12500000000000",
            "numerator": "-3145396627141151"
          },
          "label": "Change per enrollment unit, ESSER II",
          "rounding": "Exact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "An exact difference of two reported ratios.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
          "value_id": "value-esser-two-change"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-program",
          "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in each year.",
          "display": "-188.36",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-program-contributions"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "denominator": "5000000000000",
            "numerator": "-941792680599333"
          },
          "label": "Change per enrollment unit, SLFRF enrollment stabilization",
          "rounding": "Exact difference of two ratios; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "An exact difference of two reported ratios.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
          "value_id": "value-slfrf-change"
        }
      ],
      "would_change": "A revision by OSPI to either year's program-level totals."
    }
  ]
}
