Penner StrategyQuestions & evidence

School spending ยท Edition 0002

Six measures of the change

The nominal change, the change excluding the selected relief programs, each of those after each of the two consumer price indexes.

Bar chart of six percentage changes between 2021-22 and 2024-25.
The nominal change, the change excluding the selected relief programs, each of those after each of the two consumer price indexes.

Renderings of this chart

Renderings of the same plotted data; not separate research findings or chart families.

Data and reproduction recipe

Exactly the six percentage changes drawn in the statewide-change figure, in plotted order.

Published recipe files are provided as downloads. This presentation reuses the published assets without rerunning the underlying research.

ColumnLabelUnitRepresentation
measureMeasurelabeltext
change_percentChangepercentdecimal

Published plotted rows

Plotted statewide changes
measurechange_percent
All General Fund spending12.533592583495
Excluding federal COVID relief19.063405766502
Adjusted for U.S. inflation0.773922350855
Adjusted for Seattle-area inflation-1.527871273568
Excluding relief and after U.S. inflation6.621375289688
Excluding relief and after Seattle-area inflation4.186019037358

Findings that declare these chart artifacts

Edition qualifications

Citation

Published figure:

https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/assets/figures/statewide-change.svg

Source data SHA-256: 28ba56fc6ab9b1da6b434840c66784eb7f648229abe080093057df4d16329383

Figure SHA-256: 92cb7f51e6e71b590e48a2384ede3eed64d8197f75d61c9b967b811f8e9b1bc8

Complete original record
{
  "record_type": "published_chart_family_export",
  "source_edition": {
    "url": "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/",
    "release_url": "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/release.json",
    "release_id": "q-wa-school-spending@0002",
    "edition": "0002",
    "published_at": "2026-09-12T17:00:00Z",
    "evidence_cutoff_at": "2026-09-11T06:04:25Z",
    "release_sha256": "d27aa7c29adcc804fa1b7e09d90321134bad4fbcdeb0ee3beff6363d47b8235c",
    "release_bytes": 103569,
    "retrieved_at_utc": "2026-09-22T00:11:36.402249+00:00",
    "scope": "Inventory of an existing published release. No research calculations or source checks were rerun.",
    "local_release_url": "/research/school-spending/0002/release.json"
  },
  "local_url": "/research/school-spending/0002/plots/artifact-statewide-figure/",
  "published_figure_url": "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/assets/figures/statewide-change.svg",
  "chart_family": {
    "family_id": "artifact-statewide-figure",
    "label": "Six measures of the change",
    "primary_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-figure",
    "figure_artifact_ids": [
      "artifact-statewide-figure",
      "artifact-statewide-figure-detached",
      "artifact-statewide-figure-narrow"
    ],
    "data_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-data",
    "recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-recipe",
    "bindings": [
      {
        "arguments": [
          "wide",
          "0002",
          "September 12, 2026",
          "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
        ],
        "data_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-data",
        "figure_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-figure",
        "recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-recipe"
      },
      {
        "arguments": [
          "png",
          "0002",
          "September 12, 2026",
          "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
        ],
        "data_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-data",
        "figure_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-figure-detached",
        "recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-recipe"
      },
      {
        "arguments": [
          "narrow",
          "0002",
          "September 12, 2026",
          "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
        ],
        "data_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-data",
        "figure_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-figure-narrow",
        "recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-recipe"
      }
    ],
    "finding_ids_declaring_family_artifacts": [
      "f-nominal-growth"
    ],
    "panel_occurrence_ids": [
      "f-nominal-growth/p-four-measures"
    ],
    "variant_semantics": "Renderings of the same plotted data; not separate research findings or chart families."
  },
  "original_artifact": {
    "alt": "Bar chart of six percentage changes between 2021-22 and 2024-25.",
    "artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-figure",
    "bytes": 5145,
    "caption": "The nominal change, the change excluding the selected relief programs, each of those after each of the two consumer price indexes.",
    "evidence_ids": [],
    "finding_ids": [
      "f-nominal-growth"
    ],
    "kind": "figure",
    "label": "Six measures of the change",
    "license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
    "media_type": "image/svg+xml",
    "path": "assets/figures/statewide-change.svg",
    "reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
    "sha256": "92cb7f51e6e71b590e48a2384ede3eed64d8197f75d61c9b967b811f8e9b1bc8"
  },
  "original_variant_artifacts": [
    {
      "alt": "Bar chart of six percentage changes between 2021-22 and 2024-25.",
      "artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-figure",
      "bytes": 5145,
      "caption": "The nominal change, the change excluding the selected relief programs, each of those after each of the two consumer price indexes.",
      "evidence_ids": [],
      "finding_ids": [
        "f-nominal-growth"
      ],
      "kind": "figure",
      "label": "Six measures of the change",
      "license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
      "media_type": "image/svg+xml",
      "path": "assets/figures/statewide-change.svg",
      "reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
      "sha256": "92cb7f51e6e71b590e48a2384ede3eed64d8197f75d61c9b967b811f8e9b1bc8"
    },
    {
      "alt": "Bar chart of the six percentage changes with its title, date and source printed on the image.",
      "artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-figure-detached",
      "bytes": 124810,
      "caption": "The same six percentage changes as a raster copy carrying its own title, date, qualification and source address.",
      "evidence_ids": [],
      "finding_ids": [],
      "kind": "figure",
      "label": "The six measures, detached copy",
      "license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
      "media_type": "image/png",
      "path": "assets/figures/statewide-change.png",
      "reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
      "sha256": "0d9807988abb4736f1acaa468b0be3ee7687ce37f04cf9e5b6863feaa1e426ec"
    },
    {
      "alt": "Bar chart of the six percentage changes, drawn for a narrow screen.",
      "artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-figure-narrow",
      "bytes": 6613,
      "caption": "The same six percentage changes drawn for a narrow screen, with readable labels.",
      "evidence_ids": [],
      "finding_ids": [],
      "kind": "figure",
      "label": "The six measures, phone rendering",
      "license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
      "media_type": "image/svg+xml",
      "path": "assets/figures/statewide-change-narrow.svg",
      "reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
      "sha256": "c897a1e855264558c5e10ce9cc37a0e74142b539a428f314690bc475f6f20a84"
    }
  ],
  "original_data_artifact": {
    "alt": "Table of the six percentage changes drawn in the statewide-change figure.",
    "artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-data",
    "bytes": 329,
    "caption": "Exactly the six percentage changes drawn in the statewide-change figure, in plotted\n     order.",
    "data_columns": [
      {
        "definition_id": "def-per-unit",
        "key": "measure",
        "label": "Measure",
        "representation": "text",
        "unit": "label"
      },
      {
        "definition_id": "def-per-unit",
        "key": "change_percent",
        "label": "Change",
        "representation": "decimal",
        "unit": "percent"
      }
    ],
    "evidence_ids": [],
    "finding_ids": [
      "f-nominal-growth"
    ],
    "kind": "data",
    "label": "Plotted statewide changes",
    "license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
    "media_type": "text/csv",
    "path": "assets/data/statewide-change.csv",
    "reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
    "sha256": "28ba56fc6ab9b1da6b434840c66784eb7f648229abe080093057df4d16329383"
  },
  "original_recipe_artifact": {
    "alt": "Python source that rebuilds the statewide-change figure.",
    "artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-recipe",
    "bytes": 4382,
    "caption": "Rebuilds the statewide-change figure in each rendering from its plotted rows.",
    "evidence_ids": [],
    "finding_ids": [],
    "kind": "calculation_code",
    "label": "Statewide-change figure recipe",
    "license": "Penner Strategy analysis of Washington OSPI and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics public records. Reuse with attribution and with the qualifications attached.",
    "media_type": "text/x-python",
    "path": "assets/recipes/figure_statewide.py",
    "reuse_restriction": "The underlying OSPI and BLS files remain with their publishers; this package redistributes the derived tables, figures and code only.",
    "sha256": "83eaa0173facba7d5dcbea0a6a927c9c090c39aedac58505b34c7a6a1122ba06"
  },
  "original_binding_records": [
    {
      "arguments": [
        "wide",
        "0002",
        "September 12, 2026",
        "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
      ],
      "data_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-data",
      "figure_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-figure",
      "recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-recipe"
    },
    {
      "arguments": [
        "png",
        "0002",
        "September 12, 2026",
        "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
      ],
      "data_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-data",
      "figure_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-figure-detached",
      "recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-recipe"
    },
    {
      "arguments": [
        "narrow",
        "0002",
        "September 12, 2026",
        "https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-school-spending/editions/0002/"
      ],
      "data_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-data",
      "figure_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-figure-narrow",
      "recipe_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-recipe"
    }
  ],
  "original_associated_findings": [
    {
      "argument": {
        "counterevidence_ids": [
          "e-section-one-enrollment"
        ],
        "evidence_ids": [
          "e-expenditures-2122",
          "e-expenditures-2425",
          "e-enrollment-2122",
          "e-enrollment-2425"
        ],
        "panels": [
          {
            "artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-figure",
            "data_artifact_id": "artifact-statewide-data",
            "evidence_ids": [
              "e-expenditures-2425",
              "e-cpi-observations"
            ],
            "panel_id": "p-four-measures",
            "qualification_ids": [
              "qual-enrollment-measure",
              "qual-consumer-prices"
            ],
            "question": "How does the change differ across nominal and inflation-adjusted measures?",
            "takeaway": "Six percentage changes from 2021-22 to 2024-25: 12.5% nominal, 19.1% excluding relief, 0.8% after U.S. inflation, -1.5% after Seattle-area inflation, 6.6% and 4.2% excluding relief and adjusted for each inflation series."
          },
          {
            "evidence_ids": [
              "e-expenditures-2122",
              "e-enrollment-2122"
            ],
            "panel_id": "p-per-unit",
            "qualification_ids": [
              "qual-enrollment-measure"
            ],
            "question": "What are the actual dollar figures per enrollment unit behind the percentages?",
            "takeaway": "Spending per enrollment unit rose from $17,213.81 to $19,371.31; excluding relief spending, from $16,267.05 to $19,368.10."
          }
        ],
        "premise_finding_ids": [],
        "reasoning": "Each year's spending per enrollment unit is its reported General Fund total divided by its reported enrollment measure, and the change is the ratio of those two quantities.",
        "unresolved_alternatives": [
          "A different enrollment denominator would change the level and could change the percentage."
        ]
      },
      "artifact_ids": [
        "artifact-statewide-figure",
        "artifact-statewide-data",
        "artifact-aggregates",
        "artifact-growth-recipe",
        "artifact-source-verification"
      ],
      "calculation_ids": [
        "calc-statewide-growth"
      ],
      "check_ids": [
        "check-source-verification",
        "check-statewide-arithmetic"
      ],
      "check_scope": "Both totals were recomputed from the captured workbook and equal both OSPI's own total rows and the sum of the rows that carry a value in that year. The ratio and percentage were recomputed exactly.",
      "evidence_ids": [
        "e-expenditures-2122",
        "e-expenditures-2425",
        "e-enrollment-2122",
        "e-enrollment-2425"
      ],
      "finding_id": "f-nominal-growth",
      "kind": "calculation",
      "material_qualifications": [
        {
          "effect": "limits_inference",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-enrollment-definition"
          ],
          "qualification_id": "qual-enrollment-measure",
          "text": "The denominator is OSPI financial-summary enrollment, which mixes full-time-equivalent K-12 enrollment with birth-to-five special-education headcounts and various institutional programs, so it is not a count of individual K-12 students."
        },
        {
          "effect": "limits_inference",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-cpi-observations"
          ],
          "qualification_id": "qual-consumer-prices",
          "text": "CPI-U measures general consumer prices, not the prices schools themselves pay for staff, materials or services, and no school input-cost index is used here."
        },
        {
          "effect": "limits_scope",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-expenditures-2122",
            "e-expenditures-2425"
          ],
          "qualification_id": "qual-endpoint-years",
          "text": "Each comparison uses only its two endpoint school years; the years between them, including 2020-21, are not examined, even though the workbook holds other years."
        },
        {
          "effect": "limits_inference",
          "evidence_ids": [],
          "qualification_id": "qual-no-causes",
          "text": "Nothing here establishes the causes of these changes, or speaks to adequacy, efficiency, educational quality or district reserve levels."
        },
        {
          "effect": "unresolved_evidence",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-expenditures-2425"
          ],
          "qualification_id": "qual-source-vintage",
          "text": "OSPI and BLS may revise these files later; every figure here is pinned to the specific workbook and index vintage captured on 2026-09-11."
        }
      ],
      "reader_context": [
        {
          "answer": "No. It is spending divided by OSPI's financial-summary enrollment, which is not a count of individual K-12 students.",
          "context_id": "rc-per-student",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-enrollment-definition"
          ],
          "question": "Is this really 'per student'?",
          "status": "supported",
          "visible_near": "The first use of spending per enrollment unit."
        }
      ],
      "scope_id": "scope-wa-k12",
      "state": "supported",
      "text": "Washington's statewide General Fund expenditures went from $18,468,601,374.12 in 2021-22 to $21,081,063,857.94 in 2024-25. Divided by OSPI's financial-summary enrollment measure, that is $17,213.81 per enrollment unit in 2021-22 and $19,371.31 in 2024-25, a nominal increase of 12.5%. This figure is not adjusted for inflation and includes federal relief spending.",
      "title": "General Fund spending per enrollment unit rose 12.5% in nominal dollars",
      "values": [
        {
          "definition_id": "def-general-fund",
          "denominator": "The 318 of 326 listed reporting entities that report a General Fund expenditure in 2021-22.",
          "display": "$18,468,601,374.12",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-expenditures-2122"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "decimal": "18468601374.12"
          },
          "label": "General Fund expenditures, 2021-22",
          "rounding": "Rounded half-up to the cent.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "A reported total. OSPI may revise the file; this edition pins the captured vintage.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "dollars",
          "value_id": "value-expenditures-2122"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-general-fund",
          "denominator": "The 319 of 326 listed reporting entities that report a General Fund expenditure in 2024-25.",
          "display": "$21,081,063,857.94",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-expenditures-2425"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "decimal": "21081063857.94"
          },
          "label": "General Fund expenditures, 2024-25",
          "rounding": "Rounded half-up to the cent.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "A reported total. OSPI may revise the file; this edition pins the captured vintage.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "dollars",
          "value_id": "value-expenditures-2425"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-enrollment",
          "denominator": "The 319 of 326 listed reporting entities that carry an enrollment value in 2021-22.",
          "display": "1,072,894.77",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-enrollment-2122"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "decimal": "1072894.77"
          },
          "label": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment, 2021-22",
          "rounding": "Rounded half-up to two places.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "A reported total. OSPI's printed Section One table differs from the workbook for 2024-25.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "enrollment units",
          "value_id": "value-enrollment-2122"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-enrollment",
          "denominator": "The 326 of 326 listed reporting entities that carry an enrollment value in 2024-25.",
          "display": "1,088,261.99",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-enrollment-2425",
            "e-section-one-enrollment"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "decimal": "1088261.99"
          },
          "label": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment, 2024-25",
          "rounding": "Rounded half-up to two places.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "OSPI's printed Section One table shows 1,088,272 for the same year, 10.01 units higher.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "enrollment units",
          "value_id": "value-enrollment-2425"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-per-unit",
          "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in 2021-22.",
          "display": "$17,213.81",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-expenditures-2122",
            "e-enrollment-2122"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "denominator": "35763159",
            "numerator": "615620045804"
          },
          "label": "Spending per enrollment unit, 2021-22",
          "rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "An exact ratio of two reported totals.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
          "value_id": "value-per-unit-2122"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-per-unit",
          "denominator": "OSPI financial-summary enrollment in 2024-25.",
          "display": "$19,371.31",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-expenditures-2425",
            "e-enrollment-2425"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "denominator": "108826199",
            "numerator": "2108106385794"
          },
          "label": "Spending per enrollment unit, 2024-25",
          "rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to the cent.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "An exact ratio of two reported totals.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "dollars per enrollment unit",
          "value_id": "value-per-unit-2425"
        },
        {
          "definition_id": "def-per-unit",
          "denominator": "Spending per enrollment unit in 2021-22.",
          "display": "12.5%",
          "evidence_ids": [
            "e-expenditures-2122",
            "e-expenditures-2425",
            "e-enrollment-2122",
            "e-enrollment-2425"
          ],
          "exact": {
            "denominator": "16748897403263804749",
            "numerator": "209923856275273606250"
          },
          "label": "Change in spending per enrollment unit",
          "rounding": "Exact ratio; display rounded half-up to one place.",
          "uncertainty": {
            "description": "An exact ratio of two reported totals; no sampling uncertainty applies.",
            "kind": "none_quantified"
          },
          "unit": "percent",
          "value_id": "value-nominal-growth"
        }
      ],
      "would_change": "A revision by OSPI to either year's expenditure or enrollment totals."
    }
  ]
}