PENNER STRATEGYRESEARCH
  1. Research
  2. How often Washington mail ballots are rejected for arriving late

2018 EAVS totals differ by 15,611

Finding

In the 2018 EAVS file, returned mail ballots minus all mail rejections exceeds the file's own reported-counted total by 15,611 statewide. Seven counties, led by Whitman County at 13,555, carry this entire difference. The retained evidence does not explain why these federal fields disagree in this one file.

Mail ballots returned (EAVS)
EAVS field C1b: mail ballots returned by voters, regardless of outcome. This is a different, larger figure than the reported-counted total.
Reported counted (EAVS)
The federal file's own counted-ballot column: C3a in 2018 and 2020, C8a in 2022 and 2024. This is not the same as returned minus all mail rejections, which is a derived residual rather than a published field.

Why doesn't the 2018 EAVS file add up? Returned mail ballots minus all mail rejections exceeds the file's own reported-counted total by 15,611 statewide in 2018, concentrated in seven counties, and the retained evidence does not explain why.

Material qualifications

  • In the 2018 EAVS file, returned mail ballots minus all mail rejections exceeds the file's own reported-counted total by 15,611, a residual concentrated in seven counties whose cause the retained evidence does not explain.
  • In the 2020 federal file every one of Washington's 39 county rows carries the same value, -88, in field C1e, a coding convention rather than a count, and no rate in this article uses that field.

Current answer from edition 0001 · Dated September 12, 2026 · This dated edition

Evidence covers sources through September 12, 2026.

Exact quantities

Scroll horizontally to see all columns.

Each quantity with its unit, denominator and what remains unmeasured. Displayed numbers are the exact recorded quantities rounded as stated.
QuantityValueUnitDenominatorUncertainty
Returned minus all mail rejections, 20183,079,830ballotsAll 39 Washington jurisdictions in the 2018 EAVS file.An admitted quantity recomputed from the retained source at admission time.
Reported counted mail ballots, 20183,064,219ballotsAll 39 Washington jurisdictions reporting to EAVS in 2018.An admitted quantity recomputed from the retained source at admission time.
2018 partition difference from reported counted15,611ballotsThe 2018 file's own reported-counted total (C3a).An admitted quantity recomputed from the retained source at admission time.
2020 C1 partition gap-3,432ballotsThe literal sum of C1b, C1c, C1d, C1e and C1f minus C1a across all 39 Washington rows in the 2020 EAVS file.An admitted quantity recomputed from the retained source at admission time.

How the evidence supports this finding

Subtracting all mail rejections (C4a) from mail ballots returned (C1b) should, in principle, land close to the file's own reported counted total (C3a); in the 2018 Washington rows it does not, by exactly 15,611, concentrated in seven counties.

Why don't the 2018 EAVS file's own fields add up?

Returned minus rejected exceeds reported-counted by 15,611 statewide in 2018, concentrated in seven counties; the retained evidence does not explain why.

In the 2018 EAVS file, returned mail ballots minus all mail rejections exceeds the file's own reported-counted total by 15,611, a residual concentrated in seven counties whose cause the retained evidence does not explain.

Sources and calculations:

Evidence that could change the finding

A corrected 2018 EAVS file or an EAC explanation of the discrepancy would resolve this.

Sources and calculations

Scroll horizontally to see all columns.

Each cited evidence record, its exact locator and its source.
EvidenceLocatorSourcePublisher
2018 partition residualrecord: Fields C1b, C4a and C3a summed over all 39 Washington rows; no rows excluded.2018 EAVS public-release fileU.S. Election Assistance Commission
2020 C1 partition gaprecord: Fields C1a through C1f summed over all 39 Washington rows; no rows excluded.2020 EAVS public-release fileU.S. Election Assistance Commission

The 2018 residual and the seven counties carrying it were recomputed from the retained federal CSV. The 2020 C1 gap was recomputed and traced to the shared -88 sentinel value every Washington row carries in C1e; neither check explains the 2018 residual's cause.

Data, code and downloads

Every file this finding rests on. Figures carry their own download links beside them.

Later changes

Updates to this finding. Corrections and withdrawals are listed with the current answer.

Use this research

Penner Strategy. "The 2018 EAVS file's own totals do not add up by 15,611". How often Washington mail ballots are rejected for arriving late. Version 0001. September 12, 2026. https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-late-ballots/editions/0001/findings/f-2018-partition-difference/. Qualification: In the 2018 EAVS file, returned mail ballots minus all mail rejections exceeds the file's own reported-counted total by 15,611, a residual concentrated in seven counties whose cause the retained evidence does not explain.

Embed this figure

Dated figure. Its values never change.

<iframe src="https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-late-ballots/editions/0001/findings/f-2018-partition-difference/embed/" title="Dated figure: The 2018 EAVS file&#x27;s own totals do not add up by 15,611" width="100%" height="480" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<iframe src="https://pennerstrategy.com/research/washington-late-ballots/findings/f-2018-partition-difference/embed/" title="Latest figure: The 2018 EAVS file&#x27;s own totals do not add up by 15,611" width="100%" height="480" loading="lazy"></iframe>