PENNER STRATEGYRESEARCH

Archived research edition from September 11, 2026. Read the current district assessment.

WASHINGTON · ELECTIONS

Assessing November from the 31st District primaries

Using August’s vote share remains our starting estimate for each race. The historical adjustments tested so far have not established a dependable improvement.

The tests use past elections whose results are already known. November 2026 will provide a future test.

Why we reached this conclusion ↓

August primary

Senate

Phil Fortunato54.30%
Tamara Stramel45.70%

Primary lead: 8.60 points

House Position 1

Drew Stokesbary57.91%
Stephen Szczurko-Walton42.09%

Primary lead: 15.82 points

House Position 2

Joshua Penner56.07%
John Bielka43.93%

Primary lead: 12.14 points

Percentages count votes for the two named candidates in each race. Read the first investigation for the vote counts and sources.

Conditions that could change the assessment

Starting estimates for each race

Using August’s vote share remains our starting estimate for each race. The historical adjustments tested so far have not established a dependable improvement.

The tests use past elections whose results are already known. November 2026 will provide a future test.

What could change this: A historical adjustment that improves prediction under a defensible evaluation, or new evidence that changes the race comparison.

Evidence and checks

Scope: Three 2026 Washington 31st District races; shares among two named candidates. Historical tests are retrospective.

Also depends on Official candidate records support all three matchups..

Read the analysis and charts

Still unresolved
  • How close will these estimates come to the certified November results?

How much could the result change by November?

In 19 comparable races from 2022 and 2024, the middle 90% of changes ran from −1.47 to +1.30 percentage points. Across 78 races from 2014–2024, the range was −4.82 to +3.05. Both groups had an average change near zero.

These describe past elections. Two cycles cannot tell us how dependable that narrower range would be in 2026. Shared election conditions and changing district lines could both matter.

What could change this: A second sample construction, more independent election years, or a future prediction test showing a different range.

Evidence and checks

Scope: Republican-incumbent races with two named primary candidates: 78 races in 2014–2024 and 19 in 2022 and 2024, under one sample construction.

Checks completed: The analyst’s numerical checks reproduced. The choice of historical sample and its predictive usefulness remain open.

Read the analysis and charts

Still unresolved
  • Does the recent pattern survive a different method of selecting comparable races?
  • How much of the narrower range reflects conditions shared by races in the same election year?

Are we comparing the right candidates?

The state’s November candidate list, saved September 11, lists the same six candidates used in our analysis.

This checks the live candidate list at that date. The separate certification PDF still needs to be read. Both records come from the Washington Secretary of State.

What could change this: A later official correction or certification record that changes a candidate pairing.

Evidence and checks

Scope: Six candidates in three 31st District races, as listed in the saved September 11, 2026 King County query of VoteWA.

Checks completed: The saved HTML was parsed and the resulting names checked against the assumed matchups. The certification PDF was not read.

Read the analysis and charts

Still unresolved
  • Does the separate certification PDF agree with the saved live candidate list?

Checks establish the scope described beside each claim. Historical comparisons remain preliminary evidence for a future election.

Investigations

  1. September 11, 2026Primary results and historical primary-to-general comparisons

    Primary results and the November outlook

    August primary vote shares provide the starting estimate. Historical election comparisons test how much those shares may change by November.

    Completed · preliminary findings
  2. September 11, 2026Historical vote-share comparisons

    Does the recent election history change the picture?

    The average change stayed near zero. The recent races had a narrower range of changes, raising a question about how much history to use.

    Completed · preliminary findings
  3. September 11, 2026Official candidate records

    Are we studying the right November matchups?

    The saved state candidate list supports all three pairs.

    Completed · preliminary findings

Sources and supporting work

Open an entry to read the exact passage used in this edition.

Primary-election baseline
Recent-election comparison: saved results

| This reconstruction, full period (2014-2024) | 78 | -0.36pt | 0.221 | [-4.82, +3.05]pt | 7.87pt | | This reconstruction, **post-2022 only** (2022+2024) | 19 | -0.02pt | 0.935 | [-1.47, +1.30]pt | **2.77pt** |

State candidate list, saved September 11
Primary vote counts and percentages

Saved numbers used in this investigation.

Historical ranges: underlying numbers

The download includes both sample-building methods. The chart compares the two rows built with the same method.

Saved November candidate names

Names, races, party preferences and status, extracted from the saved official record. Contact fields are omitted.

Publication history

  1. Edition 8 · Current editionSeptember 11, 2026
    • First public edition of the combined assessment, with three supporting questions and their evidence.